Survivor Board vs SurvivorGrid, PoolGenius & picks sites
An honest comparison for people searching for a SurvivorGrid alternative: what each NFL survivor pool tool does, what it costs, and where Survivor Board is different.
SurvivorGrid is the original free survivor grid — win probabilities, public pick percentages, and future value in one season-wide table. If all you want is a clean grid, it remains a good free option, and its creator now funnels advanced features into a separate paid product (PoolCrunch). PoolGenius sells data-driven survivor picks and EV analysis as a subscription. Sites like RotoBaller and RotoWire publish weekly picks articles rather than planning tools.
Survivor Board keeps the free grid — live de-vigged Vegas win odds, pick share from Yahoo, ESPN, and USA Football Pools, line-movement history, and four win-probability models — and builds the planning stack around it: a season-long optimizer that understands rebuy weeks, double-pick weeks, locks, and multiple tickets across multiple pools, a tracker and weekly pick manager, and a published methodology and backtest covering the 2014–2025 seasons.
Feature comparison
| Feature | Survivor Board | SurvivorGrid (free) | PoolGenius |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free weekly grid with win odds & pick % | Yes | Yes | Paid product |
| Pick share from Yahoo, ESPN & USA Football Pools | Yes | Yes | Own projections |
| Multiple win-probability models (Vegas, empirical 2010–2025, logistic, AI blend) | Yes — 4 models | Single number | Own model |
| Line-movement history per game | Yes | Not shown | Not shown |
| Season-long pick path optimizer | Yes | In paid PoolCrunch | Yes (paid) |
| Rebuy weeks & double-pick weeks in the plan | Yes | In paid PoolCrunch | Partial (multi-entry) |
| Multi-pool, multi-ticket tracker & manager | Yes | In paid PoolCrunch | Yes (paid) |
| Strategy backtesting vs 2010–2025 seasons | Yes | No | No public backtester |
| Weekly picks pages with live data | Yes — every week | Consensus page | Articles |
| Price | Grid free; season pass $29 | Grid free; PoolCrunch paid separately | Subscription |
Feature notes reflect each product's public pages as of September 2026 — features and prices change, so check their sites. "Yes (paid)" means the feature exists behind that product's paywall.
Which should you use?
If you make one pick a week in one pool and just want a free grid, SurvivorGrid and Survivor Board will both serve you well — try both. If you want picks handed to you as articles, the weekly picks sites do that. Survivor Board is built for the player managing real stakes: several tickets across several pools with different rules, where this week's pick has to make sense eighteen weeks out. The grid is free — start there, and the optimizer is one click away when you need the full season.